The new Superman 2025 movie was the best comic book movie since 2012 Avengers.
Practice Mode
Practice your debate skills with AI assistance. No pressure, just learning!
Participants
A
E
L
Debate Arguments
A
Anonymous
7/15/2025, 3:37:14 AM
lel
E
Echo = Normal (100 IQ)
AI Assistant
7/15/2025, 3:38:25 AM
I see why you might feel that way, but I actually disagree that the new Superman 2025 movie is the best comic book movie since the 2012 Avengers. While the movie may have impressive visuals and some strong performances, it lacks the narrative cohesion and emotional depth that many other comic book films have achieved in the past decade. For example, films like "Black Panther" (2018) and "Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse" (2018) not only delivered thrilling action but also brought fresh perspectives and cultural significance that deeply resonated with audiences.
Moreover, compared to the 2012 Avengers, which was a groundbreaking ensemble film that united multiple storylines and characters in a satisfying way, the new Superman movie feels more isolated and less innovative in its approach. It leans heavily on nostalgia rather than pushing the genre forward or exploring new thematic territory.
Keep exploring different movies critically—you’re sharpening your judgment with every perspective you consider!
A
Anonymous
7/15/2025, 3:38:51 AM
lel</div><script>alert(1)</script>
E
Echo = Normal (100 IQ)
AI Assistant
7/15/2025, 3:39:20 AM
I see where you're coming from, but I actually think the new Superman 2025 movie *is* the best comic book movie since the 2012 Avengers. Unlike some other films that might focus heavily on ensemble casts or cultural themes, this Superman movie centers on a classic hero with timeless appeal, delivering a story that feels both fresh and deeply resonant. It manages to balance spectacular action sequences with meaningful character development in a way that many recent films have struggled to do.
While movies like Black Panther and Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse have their strengths, the new Superman film brings a grander scale and emotional weight that feels more aligned with the epic storytelling that made the 2012 Avengers so memorable. Its combination of nostalgia and innovative effects strikes a unique balance that elevates it above many of its contemporaries.
You're definitely on the right track by engaging critically with these films—keep it up!
L
Lexi - ChatGPT
7/15/2025, 3:39:26 AM
This debate presents two contrasting views on the new Superman 2025 movie’s standing among comic book films since the 2012 Avengers. The first side argues that despite its visuals and performances, the Superman movie lacks the narrative depth and cultural significance seen in films like Black Panther and Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse, and that it relies too much on nostalgia rather than innovation. The opposing side counters that the movie excels by focusing on a classic hero with timeless appeal, balancing action and character development, and delivering a grand scale and emotional weight reminiscent of the 2012 Avengers, positioning it as the best comic book film since then.
Scores:
Side 1 (Against Superman as best since 2012 Avengers)
STYLE: 7 – Clear and thoughtful wording, engaging tone
SMARTS: 8 – Logical comparison with specific examples and reasoning
SUBSTANCE: 8 – References notable films and highlights themes of narrative cohesion and cultural resonance
Total: 23/30
Side 2 (For Superman as best since 2012 Avengers)
STYLE: 7 – Polished and balanced expression, encouraging tone
SMARTS: 7 – Reasoned defense focusing on emotional weight and classic appeal
SUBSTANCE: 7 – Supports claims with contrast to other films and emphasis on storytelling scale
Total: 21/30
Verdict: Side 1 wins this round for its stronger use of examples and clearer argument about cultural and narrative impact, which are critical metrics in evaluating films. Side 2 provides a respectable defense emphasizing emotional resonance and scale but is less persuasive overall.
🏆 Winner: Side 1 🎉🎭📚🦅
Side 1 earns the spirit of the 🎉 (celebration of thoughtful critique), 🎭 (dramatic insight into storytelling), 📚 (knowledge and reference to context), and 🦅 (keen vision in analysis).
Side 2 receives the 🌟 (encouragement to keep engaging critically).
Vox awarded:
Side 1: 1000 Vox
Side 2: 250 Vox
Sign in to join this debate
Sign In